Search This Blog
3.03.2008
Aristotle and Choices
Aristotle uses the term voluntary which seems to correlate more with our modern idea of choice. He understands that actions done in ignorance or from compulsion do not stem from an individual’s choices. For instance, acts of racism are often blamed on ignorance. However lies we tell ourselves cannot properly be termed ignorance. True ignorance might be a situation where someone does not have information that would change the action they take. For instance if one is driving and enters an intersection not knowing that the truck coming the other way has lost his brake power he acts from ignorance. Compulsion offers an interesting qualification. If a man told me he would rape my daughter unless I did some immoral act would I do it? Would it not be my choice to act even in this case? I have the power to act or not act in this case. However, if I were tied up and dragged to a place, I am not choosing to move to that location. There is a point that compulsion takes away choice or makes actions involuntary, but it may not be as we sometimes believe. If we are the agent of action, or we act on our own power to do something that another cannot do or will not do whether we are ignorant or being compelled, we must determine if we actually do have the choice to do the opposite. If we do have the opposite choice we may be assured that our actions are voluntary. It all rests on that power to act being taken from us.
Popular Posts
-
I ran across a passage in the comments at a feminist mormon website, that sparked a response in me. The discussion was commenting on an arti...
-
I came across Ernest Hemmingway Snows at Killimenjaro at the library and brought it home yesterday. I tried to read it but didn't get f...
-
I just finished Epicenter by Joel Resenberg. It is the most remarkable book I've read in a long time. He tells about the plot lines in ...
-
Did the media think that we would suddenly turn away from Joe when they found out he owes back taxes? Holy cow- it made him more real to us ...
-
Spring is almost here! Driving through Idaho last week in the sunshine I realized how much I really love the sunshine. Nothing like going wi...
-
During the 1830s through the 1880s, many Americans moved west into the frontier in familiar covered wagons, or Conestoga wagons, pulled by t...
-
If by calling Mill’s theory hedonism, one means the elevation of bodily or physical pleasure above all else, he has in my view misinterprete...
-
I've been thinking of BY quote comparing wheat to gold and here it is .(update, Journal of Discourses website changed. This is from Jour...
-
After seeing Ron Paul interviewed regarding the economy several times, I decided to look into his philosophy and read his book The Revoluti...
-
I found this really innovative couple who began producing short video's about Mormons. They are simplified for the purpose of sharing th...